Cheap opinions
Different forms of expression and argument have different costs. I opine that opinion is cheaper than explanation or assertions of fact, because it doesn't need to rely on external sources. In short: opinion is comparatively cheap.
I was thinking about what to write this week, and struggling. It’s too late in the day to do something heavily-researched, because doing the right research and getting everything lined up well is enormously time-consuming. Doing something that's very reliant on being strongly factual is out of the question if it’s happening at the last minute. Doubly so, the few-and-far-between posts in which I do the work of explaining a scholarly text. Explaining someone else's work in a conscientious way takes even more effort than deploying facts in the service of an argument. So, slightly pressed and looking for a topic, I found myself thinking “I don’t have time for anything but an opinion.” Which is when it hit me: having an opinion is the fastest of the different argumentative or rhetorical styles I employ here. A deep analysis paired with explanation takes time. Factually supporting an argument takes time. But an opinion is fast. I can find a position, pull out some arguments I find plausible, and then go to town. It often even happens fairly automatically, because the opinion is just sitting in me, waiting to be found and articulated. This may be why opinions are pretty cheap.
When I used to get a daily newspaper, and even now, still subscribing to something weekly, I tended (or tend) to not read the “opinion” section very often. I used to rather arrogantly say “I don’t need the opinions of columnists, I can read the news and come up with my own opinion.” But of course, sometimes “opinion” is hiding a nuanced analysis from someone expert in a topic. It’s not all knee-jerk, slightly right-wing-but-in-a-slippery-way columnists who don't like change (this is the archetypical columnist that lives in my memories from my early newspaper reading days in Canada). And it’s not all just a need to write something with a fast turnaround and the right wordcount. Opinions can have merit, and at the very least, show us what someone else thinks. So an opinion can be a fine thing to have, a fine thing to read, and a fine thing to internalize. Goodness knows that the current need for pluralism in society comes from our climates of opinion formation having become very separated, with people occupying small, comfortable circles in which they don’t engage with the beliefs and opinions of others. All well and good, then, to pay attention to the opinions of others. Getting outside your mental comfort zone is a good habit. All of this is to say: there's nothing wrong with opinions.
It’s my own training, my own habituation, and my own bias (and let’s be clear, by “bias” I mean a mental shortcut, which is not an inherently negative thing) that make me feel that deploying facts or making sense of arguments are acts which have greater value and merit than deploying opinions. (I could also be prizing those things because they're assigned more professional value in my job – most peer-reviewed papers are not opinion pieces.) And it’s my own experience that makes me feel that facts require more effort and care than opinions. I can hand-wave an opinion away by saying “It’s just an opinion! I was playing with some ideas! I don't have the data to really support this argument.” I’m not making any claims to fact, or to a superior understanding of reality, when I present something as an opinion. I think that because I come from an academic background which treats the concept of “fact” very carefully, I tend to want to display the pedigree of the ideas, concepts, or numbers I’m using, if I’m doing something other than simply presenting a personal idea. It is very much my job to make sure that if I’m presenting a statement as true, it ought to have a pretty good claim to truth of some kind.
Hilariously, I came to this problem of “I don’t really have time for anything other than an opinion” because I felt that a) I didn't have the time to do justice to and b) no one would want to read about what I’ve been most intensely digging into lately – namely, the history of activism in the interdisciplinary academic field of Science and Technology Studies (STS). It’s pretty niche. I’d say that, broadly, only those who are directly engaged with STS as a field are very interested in when it was more activist, when it was less activist, and what the different intellectual threads were in those times. I do tend to feel that if an argument requires the understanding of what a “turn” is in academic parlance, the argument may not be enjoyable for a broad audience. For the record, turns are these moments in disciplines or bodies of scholarship in which a new set of ideas appears in a significant way, and potentially becomes more dominant or prominent than a previous set of ideas or ways of understanding the discipline. STS, for example, has experienced in the last twenty or thirty years a normative turn, a feminist turn, and a material turn. Are you all still awake? If so, maybe I will write about this subject one day. But not today.
The construction of different kinds of knowledge doesn’t need to be wrapped in turns and citations, and is indeed important for everyone. The differentiation between things that are presented as fact and things that are presented as opinion is, of course, extremely relevant. I’d argue that we don’t live in a post-truth world, because that gives a really excessive importance to a particular way of constructing knowledge. Instead, we live in a world in which the trappings of truth-construction are presented in an exciting array of different ways, and are deployed in a very sophisticated manner by people who have a lot to gain from having others believe very strongly in particular ideas. This need to take care with the idea of a fact, and to make sure it’s grounded in a defensible way, capable of being read and trusted by the audience to which it is being presented, is at the core of my belief that opinion is much cheaper to produce than assertion or explanation. If I am merely stating my own opinion, not much backup is needed, and I can cede the need to defend something as fact. You, dear reader, can read my opinion and decide, based on your own knowledge and your own opinions, whether you want to take it on board or not. It's much the same as my approach to reading the “opinion” section in newspapers – I will read with more interest the analysis of a correspondent whose regular work is concerned with the topic or region in question than I will read the opinion of a regular columnist writing on a given topic because it's the issue of the moment. Otherwise, I stick to the funny columns. Then I'm reading for entertainment, and an opinion or two may come along for the ride.
So, what am I trying to say here? What opinion am I expressing? Let's take it step by step. I'm suggesting, without recourse to any other sources but what I think, based on my own life experience, that factual and explanatory arguments take more time to construct and present well. They take longer in large part because they require a degree of research, and reference to sources external to themselves. An opinion-based argument can make reference to external sources, but doesn't inherently need to. It can be based just on the author's own feelings, experiences, or position. The non-necessity of external support for the opinion makes it much cheaper, time-wise, to produce. Especially if you already know what your opinion is. Research and finding external sources of support, on the other hand, costs time and effort. Finding the right information to deploy and lining it up behind whatever argument or claim it's supporting requires a lot more background work, especially if you are indeed claiming that what you're saying is some kind of fact. So opinion is a fairly affordable form of expression, in terms of the time it takes to do, when compared to other forms of articulating something.
The subtext here is that opinions are popular things to have, and popular modes of being in public tend to encourage the expression of opinions. LinkedIn thought leaders and rage-bait YouTubers alike are in the business of assertively expressing their opinions in public, and hoping that their opinions engage or influence the people reading or watching. Like the newspaper columnists, these opinions are presented as things we should pay attention to, because whatever large number of people who have viewed or liked them provide legitimacy and importance. But like I said, opinions are cheap to have, and to articulate. And because they're expressing positionality, they invite engagement – nice, easy engagement, based on the reactive opinions of the people consuming their content. None of that is really a problem.
The problem, I suppose, is when we only consume opinion. Or when we stop being able to evaluate the difference between opinion and other forms. Then we enter a sort of hall of mirrors, where we're trying to triangulate based on different opinions we hear, lacking other sources to help us make up our own minds, forming our opinions only in relation to the opinions of others. I think that's probably a problem. But the social effects of an information climate based too heavily on opinion aren't really my area, so I'd have to go and do some research to be able to make that claim with any confidence. So I'll stick to the easier claim: opinions are cheap to articulate and easy to express, because they don't require much by way of external support and they're often already sitting conveniently in our heads. Then again, that's only my opinion.